Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin Reviews & Buying Guide

A shaving cream for people with sensitive skin is not just another product that helps in shaving. A good shaving cream is a staple in your shaving den and based on your choice, and your shaving experience can range from an enjoyable and refreshing session to a dreaded messy, painful and bloody experience with the aftermath of razor burns and ingrown hairs.

Based on a few parameters and extensive research, I rounded up five products that are considered to be the best shaving creams for men (and women) with sensitive skin.

Also, there is a list of a few things to consider before buying shaving cream, which will guide you a step closer to the ideal shaving cream for you.

Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin - Comparison

Factors To Consider When Purchasing The Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

If you have sensitive skin, you cannot just pick the first shaving cream you see off the shelf at the store. Your choice should be well thought out, and the shaving cream for women and men that you choose to take home has to be favorable for your sensitive skin;

Otherwise, you will be pre-disposing yourself to frequent irritation, razor burn, dryness and other skin complications. Since shaving is something that is frequently done, you can't risk these adverse effects so here is a brief guide to help you take home the best shaving cream for sensitive skin.

Products Containing Natural Ingredients

When selecting products for your shaving routine, look for products whose formulas contain natural ingredients such as natural oils for example avocado, coconut, jojoba, and almond. Natural essential oils are ideal too. Despite their name, they are far from oily, and they evaporate on contact with the skin.

Essential oils are 100% natural concentrated essences from plants, roots, flowers or fruits. In shaving creams, most common essential oils include sandalwood, cypress, peppermint, lemon, lime, cedarwood, lavender or rose just to name a few.

Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin

Natural ingredients unlike their synthetic counterparts are easily biodegradable and work together with the body's natural cycles and functions. You have most likely used a product that wreaked havoc on your skin, so I is always a good idea to look at the ingredients list and look out for names synthetic ingredients like sodium lauryl sulfate, paraffin, mineral oil, petrolatum and anything that contains alcohol.

Shaving Creams Including Aloe Vera

If your skin is sensitive, you need to look for Aloe Vera in your ideal shaving cream. In ancient civilizations, Aloe Vera extract was used as first aid for burns and wounds and other skin conditions because it has antiseptic properties. For your sensitive skin, if Aloe Vera is one of the ingredients, then it is a huge plus.

Skin Type and Personal Preference

Certain scents are associated with certain properties, and you can pick scents basing on either your skin type or your personal preferences.

For example, scentless varieties, lavender, and rose oils are good for sensitive skin that is prone to soreness and razor burn. Cedarwood, Peppermint, and sandalwood have cleansing and caring properties and are perfect for skin that is prone to breakouts.

Lemon, Lime, and Bergamot oils are good for skin that is prone to nicks and cuts. I would recommend that you make a selection based on your skin type, but if personal scent preferences is important to you, then find a shaving cream with your ideal scent that works for you.


This is also one of the most crucial things to consider before buying a shaving cream. Even if it does not build any lather, it is important that your shaving cream offers slickness to your face.

Besides protecting your face, slickness is the top reason why the razor glides over your skin without getting stuck…on your face. If the razor cannot glide easily without getting stuck, you are pre-disposing yourself to razor burns.

Fragrance Free

For those with sensitive skin, you might consider fragrance-free alternatives, because most times, the perfumes used are the culprits behind your skin issues.

However, this mainly goes for synthetic fragrances, but also for harsh essential oils like orange and even lemon for some. Do a lot of research on synthetic and fragrances and make sure you avoid them like the plague. But to be on the safe side, you could always pick a completely fragrance free shaving cream.

Moisturizing Properties

If your shaving cream can moisturize your skin before during and after shaving, this is a huge plus. Moisturizers ensure moisture is locked in to prevent your already sensitive skin from dryness. Dryness will lead to more complications that you don't need so I would highly recommend a cream with moisturizing properties or ingredients like oatmeal.

Best Shaving Cream For Sensitive Skin Reviews

Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel

Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel

Editor's Rating:

It tops the list as the best shaving cream for sensitive skin, Aveeno Therapeutic Shave Gel boasts a unique formula.

This lubricating gel is rich and uniquely formulated with no added fragrance, making it the ideal choice for irritated skin, sensitive skin or for skin that is prone to razor bumps.

It contains ACTIVE NATURALS Colloidal Oatmeal that serves to soothe the skin, with a special blend of lubricants that moisturize the skin and get rid of dryness. Oat is a natural ingredient that is highly recommended by dermatologists.

Oatmeal as a skin protectant active ingredient can help restore the skin's normal pH and assist in maintaining the skin's moisture barrier to protect and prevent dry skin.

The therapeutic formula ensures a smooth, close shave with less irritation making it perfect for sensitive skin. It also provides protection against cuts, razor burns, and nicks while you shave.


  • Great for sensitive skin prone to irritation
  • Protects and soothes skin during shaving
  • Moisturizing lubricants that lock in moisture to hydrate skin
  • Contains soothing Active Naturals Colloidal Oatmeal
  • Protects against cuts, burns, and nicks


  • Since it is not easily soluble in water, multi-blade razors can clog heavily
  • The nozzle removes a lot of gel that might go to waste in case you need a small amount

Natural Shaving Cream, Sensitive Skin

Natural Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin

Editor's Rating:

This shaving cream for sensitive skin comes in a convenient package. It comes in a portable, squeeze flip-top tube for easy and quick dispensing and application.

It is waterproof, making it a great companion as you shave in the shower, and is portable and easy to store hence making it a great travel companion too!

The Natural Shaving Cream is unique formula contains no harsh foaming agents and irritating chemicals, making it ideal for the delicate and sensitive skin as it reduces the harshness of shaving by soothing the skin surface.

It is pure, natural and unscented, containing aloe, oatmeal sandalwood that serves to moisturize and nourish your sensitive skin throughout the shaving process. It is razor safe for men and women alike. It is also sulfate free, paraben free and hypoallergenic, so you know it is 100% safe.


  • No harsh foaming agents or irritating chemicals
  • Comes in a squeeze flip-top tube for quick and easy dispensing and application
  • Waterproof, so it is great for shaving with in the shower
  • Portable, so you can travel with it anywhere
  • Hypoallergenic, sulfate & paraben free
  • Unscented, natural and pure with natural ingredients like sandalwood, aloe, and oatmeal that moisturize and nourish your skin


  • Because it does not lather, you will need to use a lot of product

Taylor of Old Bond Shaving Cream

Taylor of Old Bond Street Shaving Cream

Editor's Rating:

Taylor of Old Bond Street provides the finest range of men's shaving gifts, and this shaving from them is no different.

It prepares your beard and face for shaving and moisturizes your face to keep it hydrated to prevent it from drying out to cause more sensitivity and irritation.

It is made of a rich woody blend of exotic cedar and sandalwood for a sweet scent, with Lavender and Rosemary for subtle floralcy and rose and jasmine for an enticingly vivacious, confidently masculine bouquet.

It comes with a bowl included that makes lathering easy. One of the main ingredients, sandalwood, is known to be good for the skin as an antiseptic and as an anti-inflammatory and an astringent. It helps keep the razor burns to a minimum.


  • Comes form a good brand name known for exceptional quality in men's shaving gifts
  • Moisturizes your face, locking in moisture to prevent dryness
  • Masculine sandalwood scent
  • Comes with a bowl that makes lathering easy
  • Has a rich blend of sandalwood, lavender, rosemary, rose and jasmine
  • Keeps the razor burn to a minimum


  • You will need a shaving brush for this product
  • The sandalwood scent is a bit strong

Neutrogena Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

Neutrogena Sensitive Skin Shave Cream

Editor's Rating:

The Neutrogena Men Sensitive Skin Shave Cream works up a thick and rich lather that helps protect your skin during shaving.

It has a formula that works on contact, to help soothe, calm and protect your skin from regular shaving irritation.

It is formulated for people with sensitive skin as it is formulated with PRO-SOOTHE Technology, which helps to provide protection against those unsightly ingrown hairs and razor bumps. It is non-comedogenic. This means that it will not clog your pores.

This blockage can result to whiteheads, blackheads, and pimples so if you take your skin seriously, consider this non-comedogenic product as it will not cause acne breakouts.


  • Formulated for sensitive skin
  • Pro-soothe technology helps fight razor bumps and ingrown hairs
  • Non-comedogenic formula ensures no clogged pores
  • Helps soothe and protect skin against regular razor irritation
  • Provides a closer shave


  • It doesn't lather, and some people prefer varieties that lather up
  • Gums up your razor and dulls it a lot quicker

Proraso Shaving Cream, Sensitive Skin

Proraso Shaving Cream

Editor's Rating:

The Proraso Shaving Cream for Sensitive Skin will most definitely transform your shaving experience into a pleasant one.

The fact that Proraso products have been made a staple in barbershops speaks volumes about the quality and the performance.

This shaving cream provides a creamy and rich lather to prepare skin that is prone to razor burns and irritation for a close shave without any problems. The formula contains oatmeal and green tea that soothe and protect inflamed, sensitive skin. It has a hint of the refreshing lime and apple scents.

It is made through a special process, known as the ‘hot soap' process where it is left to mature in small batches for 3 days. This leads to the production of a soap that is extremely fine, thick and creamy, that produces a soft and rich lather.

It contains natural based formulations with no mineral oils or artificial colors. Nourishing natural oils and botanical extracts protect the skin not only during the harsh process of shaving but also before and after shaving for an irritation-free shaving experience.


  • Has green tea in its formula that provides antioxidant properties
  • Provides a rich and creamy lather to prepare skin that is prone to razor burns for a close shave without irritation
  • Oatmeal extracts soothes and calms the skin
  • Glycerin helps the blade glide over the skin to prevent razor burn and rashes
  • Thyme extract delivers antibacterial properties
  • Refreshing lime and apple scents
  • No mineral oils or artificial colors
  • Protects your skin before, during and after shaving
  • Nourishing natural oils and botanical extracts protect the skin


  • The cap on the tube is prone to breaking away, leaving the cream to dry
  • Dries very fast

Final Verdict

So, there you have it. In my review are some of the best shaving creams for you all with sensitive skin, all tried and tested and analyzed and put in this review. Basically, all the hard work has been done for you, so you won't have to.

I have also included a brief list to consider before buying shaving cream for your particularly sensitive skin, so that buying is not a gamble anymore, and you will make a choice from an educated point of view.